Friday, May 7, 2010

Power struggle



All of the units we covered incorporated some issue that really stuck with me, so choosing one thing that changed how I observe world is hard. But a common idea that I saw linking each unit - from corn to sex change to medical disorders to global warming - was that each actions are never free from constraint or consequence. 


This problem doesn't excite me so much as bother me. After reading A Brave New World, I realized that although we as humans aren't being fed soma and micro-managed to the point of brainwashing, Mustapha Mond exists in our world in other forms. And sometimes, we are selves take his role. While studying intersex issues, it became clear that we can't always choose our own sexuality. Parents put a gender label on their children, and those children may or may not be okay with it down the road. Global warming information can be altered or misconstrued by both sides, resulting in books like Crichton which influences popular belief. The food we buy can support commodity corn and the military industrial complex, and consequently affect the environment, the government, and farmers. 


I've begun to grapple with free will as a result. Am I making my own choices, or are invisible constraints of politics, culture, and society making them for me? Or, on the other side, how are my choices affecting things that aren't inherently or immediately apparent? I've become more considerate and more careful when examining the things I buy and consume, and my personal beliefs. This class has taught me to never take things at face value, even my dinner. That may sound pessimistic or cynical, but I think its positive. To be aware of the invisible structures that shape the world makes me feel that I have a little more control over my actions because I understand how and why they come about.

3 comments:

  1. Well said Taylor. Take heart, though...even if we aren't necessarily making choices entirely of our own free will, there is such a huge number of personal factors involved (such as personal experience, desire, etc.) that it is not really feasible that someone random can guess which way our decisions will go. That is; if YOU choose, you can go against your better judgment and decide on something totally different.
    Further, even though we may have many different influences on our lives and the decisions we make, I am made more comfortable by the fact that there is never a single solitary person "pulling the strings". I won't attribute that kind of power to a single Mond.

    Have a great semester!

    ReplyDelete
  2. i totally agree that what we do can have major impacts that arent necessarily seen at first glimpse. I also agree that what will best help this is to be educated on things so that we dont have to take them at face value but can go deeper into each decison

    ReplyDelete
  3. Taylor, it is cynical, but it's also positive! I really like what you said about being more aware of influences in our life -- if we know the impact our actions have, we have the choice to be much more responsible.

    As for "free will" I don't think we have such a thing. Every single choice we make is determined ahead of time by outside forces, whether outside or inside our bodies (this is called determinism). Even an innocent decision such as "I'm thirsty, I'm going to get something to drink" was influenced by our little parched bodily cells crying out for more moisture. However there's something called compatibilism which defines free actions as made without compulsion, for example by another person. Determinism and free will are not incompatible by this mode of thinking. Whether that's BS or not it's what I've stuck to for the last few years!

    ReplyDelete